Onondaga County has 13 different police departments. Depending on where you live you may be covered by a local police department or the County’s Sheriff Department. The Onondaga County Sheriff Department provides coverage and assistance to the entire county and all taxpayers share in this cost. If you have a local police department you are paying an additional cost that is included in your city, town, or village property taxes.
Some municipalities have chosen to transition to using the County Sheriff Department. In 2008 Town of Clay residents voted 69% to transition to the Sheriff’s Department. Village of East Syracuse residents voted to consolidate their village police department with DeWitt’s in 2014.
The 2017 report of the Commission on Local Government Modernization recommended to combine police forces into one department to pool our resources, be able to deploy officers more effectively and free up tax dollars to invest in officers and technology. (page 35) In 2010, the county changed their sales-tax contributions to local governments to show the full costs of services hoping to encourage people to demand more efficiency and shared services. And New York State offers municipalities grants for transitioning to sharing services that provide cost savings, efficiency and quality services.
To get an idea of how much you are paying for policing in your municipality see the chart below and attend or contact your county, city, town and village officials with your thoughts.
*Blue = County Sheriff
* White = Local Police Department
- Budget Data From OpenBookNY
- Staffing Numbers from 2025
Related Articles & Resources
